Abeera Anwar
OP, 18, had her mom’s car since 16, but it became unsafe to drive. Her parents bought a new car, costing $4000 more than planned. They later asked for $500, surprising OP. The car is in her mom’s name, and OP expected it to be transferred to her after college. She only works in summer and a few weeks in winter due to college. OP feels it’s unfair to pay since she can’t use the car year-round, and her parents didn’t inform her beforehand. The car was bought more for appearance than necessity, and OP would have accepted any functional car. She’s willing to pay later when she can use the car regularly but feels blindsided by the sudden demand for payment. OP acknowledges her gratitude but believes the situation was mishandled. She questions if she’s wrong for refusing to pay.
1. OP wonders if refusing to pay her parents for a car they bought her makes her the j*rk.
via Reddit
2. OP, 18, had her mom’s 2010 car, which became unsafe. Her parents kindly bought her a new car, which she’s grateful for.
via Reddit
3. OP and her parents planned on a cheaper used car but opted for a pricier new one they all liked at the dealership.
via Reddit
4. OP suggested her parents choose what they thought best. Despite expecting the cheaper option, they surprised her with the new car, leaving her grateful.
via Reddit
5. OP’s parents bought the car in cash and now want her to pay $500 by summer’s end. She’s unsure when it will be transferred to her.
via Reddit
6. OP would pay once the car is hers, as she covers gas but parents pay insurance. If informed earlier, she’d have opted for the cheaper option.
via Reddit
7. OP, who attends school far away, leaves the car at home as it’s impractical on campus. Her parents also oppose bringing it to school, making payment unfair.
via Reddit
8. OP’s dad occasionally uses the car to spare his own. She clarifies her parents’ motive for buying the new car and questions if she’s wrong for refusing payment.
via Reddit
9. OP clarifies the car is under her mom’s name for insurance but will switch once she graduates. She refuses to pay, emphasizing practicality over appearance.
via Reddit
10. OP acknowledges the $500 for a new car is a great deal but feels blindsided by the sudden demand for payment without prior discussion.
via Reddit
Now that you have read the story, it’s time for you to see what Redditors had to say about this. Read till the end to see what are other people’s opinions on this. Don’t forget to share your own opinion at the end of this article.
11. Redditors are suggesting OP to save the money.
12. OP’s parents should have discussed the payment terms beforehand instead of springing it on her after purchasing the car.
13. OP’s parents should have communicated their expectations regarding payment for the car before making the purchase.
14. NTA , OP’s parents should have considered her financial situation and discussed payment arrangements with her before buying the car.
15. YTA, OP’s refusal to pay for the car, despite its benefits and her parents’ financial support, comes off as ungrateful and entitled.
16. Her parents’ lack of communication regarding payment for the car is unfair and puts unnecessary financial pressure on her.
17. ESH – While OP’s parents should have communicated better, OP should also consider contributing towards the car given her usage and benefits from it.
18. OP’s parents should have been transparent about the financial responsibility associated with the new car.
19. OP’s decision should have been considered in the process.
20. Her parents’ decision to demand payment for the car without prior discussion is unreasonable and unfair.
What are your thoughts on this story? What would you do, or how would you react if you were in OP’s position? You know that your feedback means a lot to us; therefore, we want you to share your thoughts in the comment section below. For more such articles, keep visiting Defused. Have a nice day!
Cat tax
“Our best friend passed today, he wasn’t even 2 years old.”
via Reddit
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings