AITA for Kicking My FIL Out After He Ate a Muffin Made from My Breast Milk?

You know that thing where you’re a new mom, exhausted, trying to keep a tiny human alive… and the last thing you expect is your father-in-law deliberately eating your baby’s food made from your breast milk? Yeah, that happened. And when I called him a creepy per***t and kicked him out, the whole family exploded. Now I’m questioning if I went too far — but honestly, I can’t shake the feeling that something about this is way, way off.

The Background: My Baby, My Breast Milk

The First Red Flag

The Muffin Incident

The Fallout!!

The Family Secret

The Comment That Broke My Husband

Let’s see what other Redditors have to say about this story.

In the end, this wasn’t just about a muffin. It was about boundaries — ones I set, ones he ignored, and ones I now know he’s crossed before. The history, the comments, the “accidental” tasting… it all adds up to something I can’t unsee. My husband says he’ll never look at his dad the same way again. I say my door is closed to him for good. But I can’t help wondering — would anyone out there have reacted differently, or would you have told him to get the h*** out just like I did?

What do you think?

Written by Abeera Anwar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings

AITA for Refusing to Take Back My Ex After She Left Me for a “Real Man”?

AITA for going to the gym during “women’s hour” even though I pay for it too?